10 Surprisingly Good Movies with Terrible Reviews
We all know that sometimes critics and audiences just don’t see eye to eye. A movie can get panned in reviews, tank at the box office, and still become a beloved cult classic or personal favorite.
Whether it’s campy charm, unforgettable performances, or just pure entertainment value, some films are unfairly underrated by the critics but loved by the people who actually watch them.
Here are 10 movies that critics slammed but audiences swear by — and why they’re totally worth your time.
1. Waterworld (1995)
Sure, Waterworld was notorious for going way over budget and having a messy production. Critics used to joke it was “Kevin’s Gate” and “Fishtar,” as one commenter perfectly put it: “The media pounced on Waterworld because it had a troubled production and it went over budget.”
But decades later, it’s still a water-soaked cult favorite. The over-the-top stunts, jet ski chases, and post-apocalyptic world make it a unique spectacle that audiences can’t get enough of.
Another fan shared, “Universal has had a ‘Waterworld Spectacular’ jet ski and boat show that’s run pretty much non-stop and packed to the gills every day for 30+ years. That movie kills.” If you’ve never caught the live-action show, it’s definitely worth checking out.
2. The Postman (1997)
This one got clobbered by critics for being slow and overly earnest, but many fans appreciate its hopeful message and Tom Petty-approved soundtrack. It’s a flawed movie, sure, but there’s something endearing about a world where the mail still gets delivered — even after society collapses. If you give it a chance, the quirky characters and scenic settings might just win you over.
3. Jennifer’s Body (2009)
When Jennifer’s Body first hit theaters, it flopped, and critics were confused by its blend of horror, comedy, and feminist subtext. But over time, this movie found its tribe — fans love its campy tone, dark humor, and Megan Fox’s unforgettable performance.
One fan succinctly put it: “I’m not killing people, I’m killing boooys.” It’s now a cult classic for those who appreciate a horror flick that doesn’t take itself too seriously.
4. So I Married an Axe Murderer (1993)
Critics dismissed this oddball comedy starring Mike Myers, but fans have cherished its quirky characters and quotable lines for years. It’s got heart beneath the silliness, with Myers playing double roles and delivering laughs that have aged surprisingly well. As one commenter said, “Cult classic for me and my friends! So quotable.” Plus, the soundtrack is pretty great.
5. Babe: Pig in the City (1998)
The original Babe charmed audiences and critics alike, but its sequel was seen as too dark and weird for many. However, fans of Pig in the City love its boldness and emotional depth, making it a cult favorite for those who want a story with heart — and a little edge. One fan remembered, “Loved Babe: Pig in the City almost as much as the first Babe.”
6. Matrix Resurrections (2021)
Matrix Resurrections got mixed reviews and was criticized for not living up to the original trilogy’s magic. But some viewers found it thoughtful, nostalgic, and surprisingly fresh, especially if you revisited the original films before watching.
One commenter shared, “I definitely thought Matrix Resurrections was better than all the hate it received, especially after watching the trilogy again right before I watched it.” It’s a love-it-or-hate-it experience that deserves a second look if you’re a Matrix fan.
7. Freddy Got Fingered (2001)
This movie is infamous for its bizarre humor and outrageous scenes. Critics hated it; audiences were split. But those who “get it” consider it a cult classic of shock comedy — a pure, unfiltered expression of absurdity that’s unlike anything else. “Not for everyone, but definitely a unique ride. As one fan aptly put it, it’s “A noble failure in my opinion. CHAK-SA!”
8. Enough (2002)
Critics gave Enough lukewarm reviews, but many viewers found it empowering and tense. Jennifer Lopez’s performance as a woman taking control of her life and fighting abuse has earned the film a dedicated following. As the original thread starter said, “I personally love… Enough (with JLo). Just because critics gave low ratings, doesn’t mean the audience has to. We should think for ourselves.”
If you’re intrigued by movies that polarize audiences and critics alike, you might also enjoy our deep dive into movies that are almost too bad to watch. These films often push boundaries in weird and wonderful ways, just like some of the cult classics here that found love despite (or maybe because of) their flaws.
9. The 13th Warrior (1999)
This blend of historical fiction and action adventure was overshadowed by production issues and mixed reviews. But fans love its epic battle scenes, exotic setting, and Antonio Banderas’ performance.
One fan wrote, “I like 13th Warrior. I give it a run-through at least once a year. Usually around the 19th of December.” It’s a movie that delivers excitement and a touch of history that critics underestimated.
10. Josie and the Pussycats (2001)
When it first came out, Josie and the Pussycats was dismissed as silly and juvenile. But fans now celebrate it for its sharp satire of the music industry and consumer culture — it’s clever, colorful, and ridiculously fun. It’s the kind of movie that’s better appreciated on a second watch, especially with friends. As one viewer noted, “I watch this every year.”
Movies People Only Pretend To Enjoy
Every once in a while, a movie comes out that seems to be popular with everyone. Whether it’s extremely artistically unique, an epic story, or really high-budget, something about the film has people talking. According to movie buffs on a recent message board thread, the following movies are ones that folks act as if they like to fit in with the crowd. What would you add to this list?
Read more: 11 Movies People Only Pretend To Enjoy
10 of the Best Movies with a Good Twist to Watch This Weekend
The best movies keep you guessing, totally hooked, and wanting more. Lucky for you, I’ve got a list of ten of the best movies with twists so good you’ll be glued to your screen. No spoilers, just enough to make you super curious.
Read more: 10 of the Best Movies with a Good Twist to Watch This Weekend
12 of the Most Unforgettable Movies Ever Made
If you’re up for more movie recommendations (and I know you can always find time for a great film!), here are a few unforgettable titles from a recent online discussion. These films are sure to make you think deeply about life!
Read more: 12 of the Most Unforgettable Movies Ever Made
15 Must-Watch, Mind-Bending Movies That Make You Question Reality
Let’s delve into a collection of mind-bending movies that will leave you questioning reality, unraveling enigmatic plots, and challenging your perceptions.
Read more: 15 Must-Watch, Mind-Bending Movies That Make You Question Reality
10 of the Best Sports Movies of All Time
These films remind us that no matter how tough the game gets, giving up is never an option. They teach us to keep fighting, even when it feels like the odds are stacked against us. If you’re in the mood for some competition and heart, this is the perfect list. These are the ten best sports movies of all time, straight from a recent message board discussion.
Read more: 10 of the Best Sports Movies of All Time
